Spain’s railway landscape is undergoing significant changes, particularly highlighted by the recent partnership between Talgo and the national operator Renfe . Initially, this collaboration was expected to pose fierce competition against emerging train operators, particularly in the lucrative Galician corridor . By modernizing their fleet, both companies aimed to solidify their presence and adapt to the evolving market.
However, the anticipated success has not materialized as planned, leading Spain to explore its options beyond its borders, specifically to Germany .
“They have not given the best possible result” is how Óscar Puente , Minister of Transportation, assessed the performance of the Talgo S-106 series . This underperformance has sparked a significant move, with Puente planning a visit to a Siemens factory in Germany to explore potential solutions and streamline operations. (Source).
With a pressing need to reverse the disappointing track record of Talgo trains, the intention appears to be an acquisition of German technology that could enable Renfe to regain its competitive edge against rivals such as Ouigo and Iroyo . The latter two have been making significant inroads into the market by offering low-cost high-speed options on major routes, particularly the Madrid-Barcelona corridor.
<img alt="Renfe has joined the 'Slow Luxury' With a luxury alternative to visit Andalusia: Al-Andalus with tickets at 14,000 euros" width="375" height="142" src="https://i.blogs.es/1d0e2b/al-andalus/375_142.jpeg"/>“Corporate”. This move follows the retirement of Renfe’s Avlo trains from the Madrid-Barcelona corridor, with the official rationale suggesting that AVE trains better cater to a more corporate client profile . In truth, while it is noted that approximately half of the trips in this corridor were made with AVE trains, the real reason for the Avlo’s exit appears to stem from ongoing issues with the Talgo trains themselves.
Half of Renfe’s journeys in this corridor favored the AVE trains, while the market share for Avlo had significantly lagged behind both Ouigo and Iroyo. Unfortunately, the decision to withdraw Avlo services also coincided with the operational issues plaguing the S-106 Talgo trains .
What has emerged is a metaphorical crack in the strategy of Renfe. Concerns were raised about Avlo trains developing serious structural problems shortly after their launch. Initially, there was denial regarding the issues, but these were eventually acknowledged, leading to their withdrawal from service. This has created a vacuum where Ouigo and Iroyo are left to dominate the high-speed low-price segment.
<img alt="Train liberalization in Spain has been a success for travelers. The problem is that companies are losing a money " width="375" height="142" src="https://i.blogs.es/2bf11d/guitarra-dani-renfe/375_142.jpeg"/>Recurring Problems. As Minister Puente indicated, the operational outcomes of the Talgo S-106 series have not met expectations, demonstrating significant deficiencies from the outset on routes, including the Galician corridor and lines to Asturias. Delays and breakdowns have plagued the service, drawing criticism regarding performance standards. Critiques have further compounded the frustrations surrounding the S-106’s functionality .
As the new year began, additional technical issues emerged, rendering some newly introduced Talgo cars ineffective due to computer malfunctions that resulted in delays right at the beginning of 2025 . More alarmingly, cracks were discovered within the trains themselves. The initial response included recommendations to operate at lower speeds, but it subsequently became evident that the more prudent course of action was to suspend service until the problems could be adequately addressed.
<img alt="The liberalization of the AVE has not sat at Renfe well, so now he has a plan: delaying that of close to the maximum" width="375" height="142" src="https://i.blogs.es/847c1f/renfe-cercanias/375_142.jpeg"/>The shortcomings associated with the Talgo S-106 series are particularly disheartening because these trains were envisioned as tools to provide Renfe with a competitive edge over Ouigo and Iroyo within the Galician corridor. Talgo had notably positioned itself as the only company capable of designing trains adaptable to the diverse track widths prevalent in Spain. Unfortunately, amid compromised production, the prospect of acquiring additional trains seems less feasible, placing Renfe in a monopolistic position in the short term.
With these setbacks, the disappointment within the Spanish railway sector is palpable. The hopes associated with a fleet that was meant to showcase Spain’s railway capabilities have instead highlighted operational failures and inefficiencies. As Renfe seeks solutions in Germany , the impending challenge remains to revitalize its services and regain its status in a highly competitive marketplace.
Photo | Nelso Silva and Siemens
In Xataka | Cabinas instead of traveling as sardines: Nox’s key to convert the night train into the alternative to the plane