What challenges did Laeta Kalogridis face in co-writing Another Simple Favor?
How did the creative team approach the task of surpassing the first film’s level of insanity?
What are some new settings introduced in the sequel, and how do they contribute to the story?
How did director Paul Feig adapt to unexpected challenges during production?
What insights did Feig share about the future direction of comedy in film?
When screenwriter Laeta Kalogridis came aboard to co-write Another Simple Favor alongside franchise veteran Jessica Sharzer, she was met with a difficult task. The question, she says, was, “How do you match, let alone exceed, the level of absolute insanity in that first movie? How do you get to that point where people are really genuinely surprised, but don’t feel like they’re pulled out of the film?” That question and more were answered by the film’s team — Kalogridis, Sharzer, director Paul Feig, producer Laura Fischer, and editor Brent White — during a panel discussion at Deadline Studio at Prime Experience. Check out the conversation in the video below and scroll down for photos from the event.
Recently released on Prime Video, the new film from Feig is the sequel to A Simple Favor, a darkly comedic mystery from 2018 that grossed nearly $100 million worldwide and expanded its audience on streaming amid the pandemic. Anna Kendrick reunites with Blake Lively as Stephanie, a widowed mommy vlogger who, in the original film, became entangled in the mysterious disappearance of her glamorous best friend, Emily (Lively). The sequel takes audiences from the idyllic suburbs of Connecticut to the glamorous backdrop of the Italian Riviera, where an extravagant wedding unravels into a web of mystery, deception, and deadly secrets.
Early on in development, Feig knew he wanted to shoot on the Amalfi Coast, lassoing back in a sprawling cast thrown to the wind by the double strike while introducing compelling new characters. As Fischer recalled, “it was like a five-car pileup” to execute the project from the perspective of scheduling alone. Yet the team leaned into the twists and turns of the journey, as Feig coached Lively through the process of playing multiple characters, who come together in pivotal scenes. The filmmaker had so much fun with the films he’s already hatching a third story in this world in the hopes of getting another film made before the passing of another seven years.
“The characters are fresh, and I like the places they’re in now,” he says. “They’re in very interesting places, just like the first movie put them in interesting places. And I think there’s just a lot more over-the-top international intrigue and style and fashion and crazy twists and turns to come.”
In conversation with Deadline, Feig — a comedy icon behind everything from Freaks and Geeks to Bridesmaids — also reflected on the staying power and future direction of his genre of choice, at a time when comedies have been deemed less than theatrical.
“Comedy is still definitely a group experience. But I think comedy at the moment — and look, you say this and then it changes the next day — but I think comedy has to be mixed in with another genre,” Feig explained. “Because I think audiences demand kind of a gravity and a stakes and a danger in the movies that they watch — whether it’s emotional danger, or physical danger, or whatever — and I think comedy plays best off of that.”
Another Simple Favor: Team Discusses Chances of a Threequel
In the world of cinematic sequels, few films manage to blend the finesse of mystery, humor, and drama as effectively as "A Simple Favor." Released in 2018, the movie quickly became a cult favorite, thanks to its intriguing plot, stellar performances by Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively, and its unique take on the thriller genre. With the success of the original film and a sequel titled "A Simple Favor 2" rumored to be in the works, fans are eagerly wondering: will there be a third installment? The team behind the film recently opened up about the possibility, and here’s what we know.
The Success of "A Simple Favor"
"A Simple Favor," directed by Paul Feig and based on the 2017 novel by Darcey Bell, revolves around the complex friendship between Stephanie, a mommy vlogger (played by Kendrick), and Emily, a glamorous PR executive (played by Lively). The film’s blend of dark comedy and gripping storyline captured the audience, leading to a significant box office success. The twist-filled narrative, paired with its stylish aesthetic, made it a refreshing addition to the thriller genre.
The Reception of the Sequel
In response to the positive reception, the filmmakers decided to expand the story with a sequel. The anticipation for "A Simple Favor 2" heightened fan expectations. Multiple interviews with the cast and crew have indicated their enthusiasm for revisiting the characters and further exploring their complicated dynamics. The film’s writers are reportedly keen on maintaining the original’s tone while pushing the storyline into darker, uncharted territories.
Given the sequel’s popularity, discussions about a potential third film naturally emerged. Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively, both prolific actors in their own rights, expressed interest in continuing their characters’ adventures. Kendrick stated in a recent interview that she feels there are still untold stories surrounding Stephanie and Emily. Their captivating chemistry on screen has sparked the imagination of audiences, leading many to wonder how their relationship might evolve in another installment.
Director and Writer Perspectives
Director Paul Feig, known for his stellar work in comedy and thriller, is no stranger to crafting narratives that balance humor with suspense. His creative vision for the sequel focused on deeper character development and escalating stakes. When asked about the prospects for a threequel, Feig suggested that the series remains open to exploration. He emphasized that as long as there’s a compelling story and the right ideas, he is excited about the potential of bringing a third film to life.
The writers also hold a key role in the direction of any future installments. They aim to inject fresh ideas while retaining the essence that fans loved about the original movie. Sources close to the creative team have revealed that they are actively brainstorming potential plots. Central to their discussions is the idea of taking the narrative in unexpected directions, possibly introducing new characters who could add depth to the existing story arc.
Fan Engagement and Social Media Buzz
In today’s age, fan engagement plays a significant role in shaping a franchise’s future. Social media platforms have been abuzz with discussions regarding the series. Fans have taken to Twitter, Instagram, and various forums to express their excitement and hopes for a third film. The hashtag #AnotherSimpleFavor has gained traction, with many users sharing their theories and desire to see more twists and turns in the story.
Highlighting the importance of fan feedback, Kendrick mentioned in an interview that the enthusiasm of the audience is a major motivator. She acknowledged the incredible support from fans and hinted that their reactions would undoubtedly influence any decisions regarding a threequel.
The Challenges of Sequels
While the potential for a third installment remains enticing, the team is aware of the challenges that accompany sequels. Maintaining originality while delivering a fresh experience can be tricky. There’s also the pressure of meeting audience expectations, particularly when a sequel follows a successful predecessor. The filmmakers need to strike a balance between creative integrity and market viability.
Feig has mentioned that he is cautious about moving forward without a solid narrative foundation. He believes that if the story resonates and brings something new to the table, fans will be more likely to embrace a sequel. This careful consideration highlights the commitment of the team to delivering quality content, rather than rushing into a third film without a compelling reason.
Conclusion
As discussions around a potential third film in the "A Simple Favor" franchise continue, excitement builds among fans and the creative team alike. The chemistry between Kendrick and Lively, coupled with Feig’s directorial prowess and the writers’ innovative ideas, creates fertile ground for a vibrant narrative tapestry. While there are hurdles to overcome, the enthusiasm and passion for the franchise signal that the story isn’t done just yet. Whether or not "Another Simple Favor" becomes a reality, one thing is certain: the impact of its characters and storyline will resonate long after the credits roll, leaving fans eagerly hoping for another thrilling ride.
"Another Simple Favor," the sequel to the 2018 film "A Simple Favor," premiered at the South by Southwest Film Festival on March 7, 2025, and became available for streaming on Amazon Prime Video on May 1, 2025. (nerdist.com) The film reunites Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively as Stephanie Smothers and Emily Nelson, respectively, with the story set in Capri, Italy, where Emily is preparing for her wedding to a wealthy Italian businessman. (thewrap.com)
The sequel has received mixed reviews from critics. Some have praised its bold storytelling and stylish aesthetic, while others have criticized its convoluted plot and underutilized talent. (ft.com)
Director Paul Feig has expressed interest in a third installment, stating, "It would be fun. We’re definitely set up for one. There’s more fun stuff to be done with these characters." (soapcentral.com) However, no official plans have been announced yet.
As of now, "Another Simple Favor" is available for streaming on Amazon Prime Video.