What are the key challenges that HIVE Blockchain Technologies faces in the current bitcoin mining landscape? How has Frank Holmes adapted his strategies in response to shifts in the cryptocurrency market? What advantages does HIVE’s use of green energy provide in the competitive mining industry? In what ways has the transition from Ethereum’s Proof-of-Work to Proof-of-Stake impacted HIVE’s operations? How does the company’s decision to recycle GPUs for AI purposes reflect broader trends in technology and energy consumption?
Frank Holmes has had a long career as a money manager: financing gold mining companies; getting involved in the creation of gold royalty companies; developing financial products for the airline industry — all of this with U.S. Global Investors (GROW), the publicly-traded asset management firm he’s been leading since 1989. He’s also the chairman of HIVE Blockchain Technologies (HIVE), a bitcoin mining company with a $345 million market capitalization and a rapidly expanding footprint in Paraguay, thanks to a recent deal in which the firm acquired facilities previously owned by another miner, Bitfarms. The firm was born, he said, after he attempted to launch a spot bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) in 2017. HIVE has been green from the get-go. Its first facility used geothermal energy in Iceland; another used hydro-power in Sweden, only 100 kilometers south of the Arctic Circle. Now, the company expects to have roughly 430 megawatts (MW) of infrastructure up and running by the third quarter of 2025 — meaning enough energy to power a city of 86,000 homes.
Holmes will be speaking at the BTC & Mining Summit at Consensus 2025, in Toronto on May 14-15. In the lead-up to the event, Holmes shared his thoughts about HIVE’s situation within the broader mining industry, the company’s decision to recycle its GPUs for AI purposes, and what the future holds.
This interview has been condensed and edited for clarity.
CoinDesk: HIVE has been repurposing some of its GPUs for AI. Can you tell me about that?
Frank Holmes: At one time we had 130,000 AMD chips and we were mining ether (ETH). We were about 6% of the world’s ether mining and it was very profitable. When that went away [with Ethereum’s transition to Proof-of-Stake in 2022], we had this expertise in GPU chips and we replaced a lot of our AMD chips with Nvidia chips. That allowed us to start going down the AI path.
The difference between a basic ASIC miner and Nvidia chips is like driving a Bronco and a Ferrari. The delicacy of the motor, the engines, all the gearing that goes into a high-performance car — all of that relates much more to a GPU. When Antminers S21 Pros show up, it takes us six hours to unwrap them and plug them in. When the Nvidia chips show up, like an H100, it’s six weeks before you’ve built the brain and it’s working. So it’s a completely different skill set.
When you’re building infrastructure for bitcoin mining, you’re spending a million dollars per megawatt of electricity. When you go into high-performance computing (HPC), the facilities need so much redundancy that you spend $10 million per megawatt. That’s excluding the equipment. You’ve got much higher logistical engineering requirements, and you’ve got much higher capital expenses.
When you want to source energy for bitcoin mining, you can take variable energy, and the real key part is the cost of the energy. In Sweden, we can go from 30 megawatts to three megawatts in 15 seconds. So we’re able to give back energy, or take it on.
When you’re HPC, you have to be up all the time, and so you need to have this backup of generators, batteries. Stability of energy is much more critical for HPC than it is for bitcoin mining. So you have a matrix that you’re trying to play with.
Does the Trump administration’s tariff strategy impact your operations?
We listen to the U.S. because it’s so important for branding and liquidity. But we never did anything in the U.S. because we’re always concerned about the overreach of regulatory agencies in Washington. They basically weaponized the auditors to go after anyone that was in crypto. So we said, ‘Let’s just stay neutral in this jurisdiction.’ Then Trump won, so we decided to move our head office over. That’s strategic, because if your head office is in the U.S., you qualify for many of the various indexes. We don’t have mining operations in the U.S. yet.
But you’ve expanded significantly in Paraguay.
I think what happened in Paraguay to Bitfarms is that they went through some distraction with their CEO [left]. There was a vacuum. Then Riot (RIOT) tried to come in to buy and control them. During that turmoil period, the Paraguayan government put a tariff on bitcoin miners, which was really very weird, but it happened, and it will drop away, I think, next year. It was all unsettling for the new CEO, and he wanted to pivot to the U.S. So they merged with Stronghold (SDIG) to basically become an American company, like a reverse takeover.
They still have 80 megawatts of electricity in Paraguay, but most of the operations we’re now taking over. We’re finishing the construction, and we’re very excited about it. We already have a few machines working. We have the biggest growth profile in 2025 of all the bitcoin miners. We have not done any of these funky convertible debentures to buy bitcoin. Most of them paid much higher prices. No, we’ve not done that because we know how volatile it can be. Every time everyone starts doing this binge debt buying — well, before, in 2021 it was all for buying mining equipment. This time, it’s all for buying bitcoin. Bitcoin then goes to a correction, and they all get strangled. We just don’t want to be in that position.
We really see the opportunity in Paraguay. It has the largest dam in the Western hemisphere, shared 50/50 with Brazil. It’s 14 gigawatts and like eight kilometers long. It’s so immense. If Paraguay doesn’t use the electricity, then Brazil gets to keep it. Well, Bitcoin miners don’t do that. We help build out their infrastructure, and they get paid U.S. dollars every month. So it’s a win-win for the Paraguayan government and it’s a win-win for HIVE shareholders because we want to stay focused on green energy.
Are there other jurisdictions you’re looking to expand to?
We’re looking at proposals coming from East Africa. Ethiopia in particular has a lot of stranded electricity. Some of the other miners have already gone into that area. They got all this cheap money from the World Bank and other institutions, and they built the dams, but then they didn’t build the power lines throughout the economy. It’s a big expense. We have a very clear vision to go from 6 EH/s to about 25 EH/s in the next nine months.
How do you see the mining industry’s situation right now?
I don’t think it’s healthy. You have to be cognizant that there’s a change for a lot of the big miners. Major U.S. corporations are not really into mining expansion. They’re predominantly focused on adding bitcoin to their balance sheet. They’re all emulating Michael Saylor’s business model. But for Bitcoin’s ecosystem to function, you need to have growth in the nodes. You need to have growth in mining operations so we become even more decentralized. Some of the companies should probably be investing more in the Lightning Network or in Ordinals infrastructure to differentiate themselves.
What Bitdeer (BTDR) is doing [with ASIC manufacturing] is really smart. The founder was also a co-founder of Bitmain. So coming in with a new piece of technology which is very energy efficient in terms of joules consumed, I think that’s very good and competitive for the capital markets.
Bitcoin miners are going to go through a process that happened to the gold miners. When the GLD came out for bullion, all of a sudden there was a separation — gold stocks versus the GLD. This century, gold bullion has outperformed the S&P 500 by a wide margin. But only the quality gold stocks, the royalty gold stocks, have actually outperformed. One of the things that HIVE has always had is the old royalty model of high revenue per employee so that we can deal with these down drafts and not have to go through this panic of big layoffs.
Hive’s Frank Holmes on Expanding Bitcoin Mining in Paraguay
In the rapidly evolving landscape of cryptocurrency, Bitcoin mining has become a focal point of interest due to its potential for significant profit, energy consumption concerns, and the geopolitics surrounding digital currencies. Frank Holmes, the Executive Chairman of Hive Blockchain Technologies, has recently made headlines with his focus on expanding Bitcoin mining operations in Paraguay. This article delves into the motivations, implications, and potential of Hive’s initiatives in this South American nation.
The Appeal of Paraguay for Mining Operations
Paraguay has emerged as an attractive destination for cryptocurrency mining due to its unique combination of abundant hydropower resources and favorable regulatory conditions. The country generates approximately 99% of its electricity from renewable sources, primarily hydroelectric plants like the Itaipú Dam, one of the largest hydroelectric facilities in the world. This abundant energy supply is crucial for Bitcoin mining, which is notoriously energy-intensive.
Frank Holmes believes that Paraguay presents an optimal environment for Bitcoin mining companies due to its low electricity costs, estimated to be among the lowest in the world—sometimes even lower than $0.03 per kilowatt-hour. This aspect alone can make mining operations substantially more profitable than in regions where electricity rates are considerably higher.
Moreover, Paraguay has been proactively fostering a welcoming environment for technology and cryptocurrency. The government has expressed interest in promoting cryptocurrencies, which aligns well with Hive’s goals. Holmes sees this synergy as a vital factor in Hive’s strategic decision-making process.
Benefits of Mining Expansion
The expansion of Bitcoin mining in Paraguay is not merely a business opportunity; it also holds transformative potential for both Hive Blockchain Technologies and the local economy. By establishing substantial operations in Paraguay, Hive can leverage local resources to increase its hash rate—one of the key metrics that denote the processing power of the Bitcoin network.
Frank Holmes has articulated his vision of creating jobs and fostering economic growth in Paraguay through Hive’s operations. By setting up mining facilities, Hive can contribute to local employment opportunities, particularly in regions that may be underserved by traditional industries. The influx of investment capital and technological expertise can stimulate further economic development, positioning Paraguay as a key player in the global cryptocurrency market.
Additionally, Hive’s presence could lead to technological knowledge transfer. Local businesses and young entrepreneurs can gain valuable insights into blockchain technology, mining economics, and the intricacies of cryptocurrency trading. Holmes believes that this educational component is essential for nurturing a tech-savvy workforce in Paraguay.
Environmental Considerations
As sustainability becomes an increasing concern for many sectors, Bitcoin mining’s impact on energy consumption and carbon output has drawn scrutiny. Hive’s commitment to sustainability, particularly its use of renewable energy, is well aligned with Paraguay’s renewable energy profile. By tapping into Paraguay’s abundant hydropower resources, Hive can mitigate the environmental impact commonly associated with Bitcoin mining.
Holmes argues that investing in renewable energy is paramount, and companies like Hive have a responsibility to embrace sustainable practices. By fostering a green mining operation, Hive can demonstrate to the world that Bitcoin mining can coexist with responsible energy consumption. This stance not only enhances Hive’s brand image but also sets a precedent within the industry, influencing other mining enterprises to consider their environmental footprint.
Challenges on the Horizon
While the prospects for Bitcoin mining in Paraguay are promising, it is crucial to recognize the potential challenges that could arise. Regulatory hurdles, although currently favorable, can change rapidly. The cryptocurrency landscape is fraught with legal ambiguities, and any adverse regulatory changes could hinder Hive’s expansion efforts. Holmes has emphasized the importance of engagement with local authorities to ensure compliance and foster a collaborative approach towards forming sustainable regulations.
Moreover, volatility in Bitcoin prices can significantly impact the profitability of mining operations. While the current enthusiasm surrounding Bitcoin presents a lucrative opportunity, market fluctuations can be unpredictable. Holmes is aware of the need for diversification and strategic planning to manage the financial aspects of their operations effectively.
Conclusion
Frank Holmes’ vision for expanding Bitcoin mining in Paraguay reflects a calculated approach to harnessing local resources while contributing positively to the local economy. By capitalizing on Paraguay’s renewable energy, Hive Blockchain Technologies is not only positioning itself strategically in the global Bitcoin mining market but is also advocating for a sustainable future for cryptocurrency.
As Hive establishes its operations, its impact on job creation, local economies, and the environmental agenda will be closely watched. Should Hive successfully navigate the challenges while realizing its ambitious plans, it could very well set a benchmark for cryptocurrency mining ventures across the globe, establishing Paraguay as a new frontier in the digital currency landscape. The balance between profit, sustainability, and community engagement will be critical as Hive charts its course in this emerging market.
Frank Holmes, the CEO of Hive Blockchain Technologies, has expressed interest in expanding Bitcoin mining operations in Paraguay. The country is becoming an attractive destination for cryptocurrency mining due to its low electricity costs, primarily derived from hydroelectric power.
Paraguay hosts the Itaipu Dam, one of the largest hydroelectric plants in the world, providing abundant and cheap energy, which is crucial for the energy-intensive process of Bitcoin mining. This has drawn attention from various mining firms looking to optimize operational costs.
Hive Blockchain, with its focus on environmentally friendly and sustainable practices, sees Paraguay as a strategic location to tap into these resources. The move aligns with the growing trend of cryptocurrency companies seeking to establish bases in areas with favorable regulatory environments and low energy costs.
Holmes has highlighted the importance of expanding operations to stay competitive, particularly as Bitcoin mining becomes increasingly dominated by jurisdictions that can provide sustainable energy and favorable economic conditions. By leveraging Paraguay’s resources, Hive aims to enhance its mining capabilities and contribute to the broader cryptocurrency landscape in the region.
This potential expansion also reflects the ongoing evolution of the cryptocurrency mining industry as companies adapt to market conditions and regulatory frameworks, striving to maintain profitability while adhering to environmental standards. In this context, Hive’s initiative in Paraguay underscores the importance of location and resource management in the future of Bitcoin mining.